This blog proposes to examine the question in terms of my personal family. Tradition says we’re German. Traditional genealogy can’t get the paternal side of my family past Pennsylvania in the late 18th century. So what are the alternatives, and what do we know so far?
Haplotype- Paternal (ftDNA): R-P312 -> Z39300+ -> R-BY15581
Haplotype- Paternal (Yfull): R-P312 -> R-PH2278
Big Tree Location: Here.
Tests completed: Nat Geo Genographic 2.0, P312 SNP test suite, DF27 test, Y111, Big Y
(Some) YDNA Matches: Myers DNA Project, R1b, Lineage X. It is best to open the page in a new window, then save the web page and search offline. Otherwise the page takes forever to navigate. Note that new privacy restriction have made it harder to show data here.
More (not all) matches can be found in ftDNA’s P312 project. The match to the Feicht family is via Ysearch.
For those wondering where the blog articles are, click on the phrase “Blog” above and a bit to the right. You can also reach them via ‘search’, or click on the element in the tag cloud that seems most suitable.